6 October 2026
The best salesperson is not the best candidate for manager
A capital target determines what income you need, not the other way round. And once the target is calculated, the same thing almost always turns out: saving will not close the gap, because spending has a floor and income has no ceiling. The most common way to raise income is to grow in your role inside a company, and here I can tell you how it looks from the other side of the table: for many years I have been the one deciding whom to promote.

In 2021 I was leaving the division of bank representatives in the premium segment, and I had to leave the team a successor. I chose a young woman, a representative who had by then been working with the bank for 4 months. In sales she was in the top 3-4, but not first: I looked at more than sales.
How she came in
Bank representatives are field staff who travel to meet clients and sign them up for the bank's products. Before the pandemic each had 10-14 meetings a day, and when everyone suddenly wanted to be served remotely, the volume grew several times over and in peak months reached 30-40. Not everyone could bear the load, and some representatives ended their contracts with the bank and left.
The bank faced one of the key challenges of that period: to carry this load so that as many people as possible who wanted to become clients actually did. And a bad experience when getting a card could put someone off working with the bank once and for all.
What we had to do then: instead of a week-long training programme and an internship with an experienced representative, after which it would be clear how well a person fitted the role, there was an hour-long briefing on the representative's tasks and 2-3 of the simplest meetings, after which the person had to return to the office and make sure all the meetings had been carried out correctly. After the briefing half dropped out - those who realised the work was not for them. A further third dropped out after the meetings, with the words «this is not for me».
She passed both rounds of attrition and learned on her own, as she worked, with the help of internal systems where product information can be found quickly. When the load grew to 20-25 meetings a day, she coped without failures or complaints, although nobody had really trained her.
Then I gave her 2 tests. The first was to reach high results, and she did almost at once. The second was to informally lead 2-3 colleagues and help them raise their own figures, including those who had worked with the bank longer than she had. She managed that too, and by the time I left, the question of a successor was settled.

What happened to the strongest salesperson
We also had the opposite case in the division. The strongest bank representative was appointed acting sales supervisor. Six months later it was clear he was not managing, and he went back to being a representative, and 3 months after that he ended his cooperation with the bank.
Not everyone can bear returning to the ranks of those they supervised yesterday, and most often a person in that situation leaves. Hence the rule I took away: a manager is not appointed on credit; the one appointed is the one who is already ready.

Why the best salesperson is not the best candidate
Let me say at once that I do not consider the best salesperson a bad candidate. The best salesperson is not the best candidate for manager, and there is a big difference between those two statements.
To become first in the ranking, a person develops what works for himself: he finds his own ways of reaching targets and is in no hurry to share them. A manager needs the opposite - to give knowledge away and to take pleasure in results being produced by others, even if one of them eventually overtakes him.
A good salesperson from the second or third line of the ranking is often built differently: he competes with his own yesterday self and helps the team catch up. The top performer more often works for his own figure, helps others reluctantly, and may treat someone else's success, if it threatens his place, with disdain.
And here is what follows: when choosing a manager, I look not only at how much a person sells, but at what happens with the colleagues around him.

What yesterday's best salesperson does in the first months
I see two mistakes most often.
The first. He demands of the team what he demanded of himself, but people do not have the same skills, and he does not yet know how to teach them... and he starts burning the team out: rigid frameworks, discontent, burnout, departures. Understanding that others are built differently from him usually takes about a month alone.
The second. He sells for his staff. The right way is to come to the meeting together, intervene hardly at all, write down how it went, and then go through with the employee what could have been done better. Instead he takes over the conversation and closes the deal himself. That meeting goes better, but the employee learns nothing, and the manager goes on selling for his team.
For the manager himself this shows in money too: by my estimate, a former top salesperson's income in the first year can fall by up to 30%. About 3 months go on stopping measuring the team against himself, and another 3-9 months on learning to pass skills on.

How I test a candidate before the appointment
With me, a candidate first shows the work of a manager and only then gets the post. The order is as follows:
- A conversation about whether the person wants to manage and why. It is better when he comes with this himself - that is a sign of maturity. Wanting and being able are different things, so next comes an assessment of aptitude.
- He is given 2-3 colleagues, 4 at most, and brings a plan: how he will understand their strengths and weaknesses and what he will do about it.
- If the plan is convincing, he works with the group for at least 6 months. 1 strong quarter may be chance, 2 in a row is already a pattern.
- He is not paid extra for the group during this time: he receives his usual salary.

I am asked whether this is exploitation. I do not think so. A manager's salary is paid for a manager's skills, and at this stage nobody has yet seen them. The candidate, meanwhile, is trusted with a piece of the business together with its risks, and is asked for one thing in return - to show it in practice.
For the candidate it is also safe. If it does not work out, nobody removes him from a post: he sees what was lacking, works on it and tries again. Someone sent back from a management position after six months will not be in that situation - he has to live with the thought that he took a place that was not his, and that consumes many people.
If an employee wants to manage and I see that he cannot yet cope, I do not say «you will not cope». I say what needs to be done to be able to, and we draw up an individual development plan. That way he understands why he is not yet being considered, and I do not lose a strong person to resentment.
How it was for me
When I was a mentor to representatives in Saint Petersburg, I gathered my group, 6-7 people, at 8 in the morning at the McDonald's on Alexander Nevsky. We discussed how to build an offer for a client, set targets for the month and got to know each other better... everyone came.
Almost nobody saw these meetings. I was appointed to a management role later, for the group's results and for ideas about the division's work beyond my own duties: I had always treated the place where I work as my own company, and people like that get noticed.
In short
In sales you become a manager before the official appointment: first the person shows that he can produce results through other people's hands, then he gets the post. And for the team to really follow him, he needs trust and respect - I have a simple formula for this: trust multiplied by respect gives influence.

The rule I took away for myself: it is better to promote the one beside whom others grow than the one who sells best himself.
And for your capital, here is what follows: a promotion is the strongest lever for growing income, but in the first year in a new role it can work in the minus, so build this into your capital growth plan in advance and begin preparing for the role you want before you want to take it.
And now your experience: the last time someone became manager in your team, was it the best salesperson or the one people went to for advice?
About the figures: the estimate of an income fall of up to 30% in the first year is the author's personal estimate from observing his own division, not market statistics. The timings and attrition shares describe a specific period, 2020-2021.
This is not individual investment advice.
Rafail Kasymov - Senior Managing Director in the Private Banking division of one of the largest banks in the country. Every day I see how wealthy clients manage their capital. I write about putting your own money in order and running it by the same rules - and about how banks work from the inside.